BY MIKE KILLBREATH
CCN Executive Editor
FLINT (CCN) — Monday's (Oct. 14, 2024) Flint City Council meeting was canceled by Flint police after an incident with amily members of former Councilman Quincy Murphy who recently passed away. Reports from witnesses say a gun was pulled to end arguing with a woman who obtained signatures on recall petitions to remove the first-term councilman from office.
Multiple videos reviewed by The Daily Gazette show that the group who disrupted the meeting, estimated to be between nine or 10 individuals, stormed from the back of the meeting about an hour after it began. Multiple witnesses told The Daily Gazette that every member of the group was a family member of Quincy Murphy and a few said some may have been close friends.
Several could be heard on video shouting various comments about their relative.
Another video surfaced later in the evening with family members discussing how they had targeted Beverly Biggs-Leavy and City Councilwoman Tonya Burns in a stunt that they claimed City Council President Dr. Ladel Lewis was aware of because she had encouraged them to do it.
Dr. Lewis could not be reached for comment by The Daily Gazette because she has unfriended us on Facebook and does not respond to our phone messages or texts. She did, however, release a statement to WJRT ABC TV 12 News. She reported that the incident was "triggered" by something said by a family member with an individual who was seeking an appointment to Quincy Murphy's vacant seat, saying, "That caused a back-and-forth. And so from there, that family member came around and things continued and another family member of the candidate came around and pulled out a firearm."
She also told ABC TV 12 that she does not feel safe at city council meetings, saying, "Seeing that people have guns and are willing to pull them out, absolutely not. I don't feel safe. I speak for myself. I do not feel safe coming to do my job to serve the residents."
Dr. Lewis, a first-term council member who represents the 2nd Ward, has been given police rides to and from past city council meeting because of what she called "death threats" although no police investigation has ever been publicly mentioned to confirm that she has faced any threats.
A dispute with a fellow council member made national news earlier this year when Dr. Lewis held a press conference with a pastor to allege racist behavior by a colleague. Dennis Pfeiffer, a first-term Councilman for the 8th Ward, had joined 6th Ward Councilwoman Tonya Burns and the late 1st Ward Councilman Eric Mays in quizzing Dr. Lewis and Quincy Murphy about gifts they received from Ashley Capital prior to voting on million dollar deals for the company to build something on the old Buick City site in north Flint. While grilling Quincy Murphy who admitted getting an $11,000 lawn mower and $4,5000 in cash from Ashley Capital prior to the vote, Councilman Pfeiffer claims he mistakenly said "the monkey in the room" instead of saying the "elephant in the room" as he insisted was intended.
Financial filings with the state revealed the lawn mower being donated to a non-profit that steered it to Quincy Murphy as well as a $1,500 donation to a non-profit started by Dr. Lewis for a park.
Prior to the group storming to the front of the city council chambers, Dr. Lewis directed a comment to Councilman Pfeiffer about the monkey comment months ago.
Multiple videos reviewed by The Daily Gazette show that Dr. Lewis then sat and watched without calling anyone to order as the group disrupted the meeting by rushing to the front of the chambers, yelling obscenities and approaching Biggs-Leavy.
"Any other time someone such as me says something she doesn't like, she's ready to throw people out of the meeting," noted community activist Arthur Woodson in a Facebook Live video he posted a day later about Dr. Lewis.
Mayor Sheldon Neeley was quoted by ABC TV 12 with a comment presented on the screen that the incident was because of medal detectors at Flint City Hall being taken down after a community activist filed a lawsuit claiming the city can't legally install medal detectors which can only be done at school buildings, courts and airports.
Woodson reacted by saying, "Yeah, he wants to blame me for every problem." He also alleged that he feels it was "all a setup deal" and two council members (Pfeiffer and Burns) made the same allegations in an interview the next morning on The Bump, a weekday podcast hosted by Wyntis Hall on 810NewsMediaGroup.
Woodson was also angry that ABC TV 12 only quoted the mayor and city council's President without asking anyone else what happened.
The rest of Mayor Neeley's statement was as follows: "The safety of residents is our number one priority, and we are very alarmed by the incident that took place tonight. I want to thank the Flint Police Department and all assisting agencies for their quick response to de-escalate the situation. We have witnessed incendiary political rhetoric across our nation and close to home, and we have done everything in our power to make Flint City Hall safer. We have security guards in place during operating hours and implemented new security measures throughout the building. Citizens and stakeholders should be able to engage in the work of government without fearing for their safety, and we will continue to work with the Flint Police Department to ensure that public meetings are safe."
No statement was issued before Monday's late night TV newscasts by officials at the Flint Police Department who arrested nobody at the scene. Only one officer was at the city council meeting instead of two as normally is the case, according to multiple sources.
After the late news reports, the police department issued the following statement: "This evening at 6:37 PM, the City of Flint Police Department received a 911 call regarding a disturbance at a regularly scheduled city council meeting. Reports indicated that several attendees were engaged in a verbal confrontation that escalated to a potential physical altercation. Before officers arrived at the City Council chamber, additional reports surfaced indicating that one individual was armed with a firearm. Upon their arrival, officers encountered a female subject in possession of a firearm, which was confirmed to be legally possessed. Responding officers acted swiftly to re-establish order in the chamber. Following their intervention, the city council meeting was adjourned. At this time, no arrests have been made, and the situation is being monitored by the City of Flint Police Department. The safety and security of our community remain a top priority. The City of Flint Police Department continues to urge all residents to report any suspicious activities or disturbances promptly."
Biggs-Leavy, who was one of four candidates to be interviewed Monday night for an appointment to replace Quincy Murphy as the city's 3rd Ward representative, issued a statement about the uprising that criticized the council's President and Vice President.
She said as follows: "The events at the Flint City Council meeting were regrettable and could have been avoided if the council President and Vice President had taken action. I was looking forward to an interview for a potential appointment to the council but unfortunately, this was overshadowed by a disruptive group of about 20 individuals who attempted to intimidate me from seeking the 3rd Ward council seat. These individuals acted aggressively from the start of the council meeting, without any warning from council. My family and I were being threatened by the aggressors while council watched without calling order. They tried to physically harm me and my family. We rightfully defended ourselves from the threats and attacks. Thankfully, my family was there to protect me as there was no proper police presence (there). Unfortunately, Flint City Council President Ladel Lewis did not take any action to prevent the turmoil which I believe was exacerbated by her ties to the offending family. Despite this, I remain determined to support the residents of Flint and the 3rd war by running for the 3rd Ward council seat. I am grateful for the support of everyone."
A.C. Dumas, Rich Jones and Kerry Nelson are also seeking to replace Quincy Murphy. They were in the audience awaiting interviews, too.
All four candidates are also on the ballot in two weeks but Genesee County Clerk Domonique Clemons and state officials have declared that vote totals won't count because the individual being recalled died before the election. Biggs-Leavy, who led the petition drive to get the recall on the ballot, has filed a lawsuit to challenge the decision not to count the Nov. 5 ballot results.
Councilwoman Burns said she called 911 as soon as she saw Quincy Murphy's family members charging toward the council at the front of the room. She called it an "insurrection" on Flint's elected officials.
Her statement on social media was as follows: "Flint had its own insurrection as elected officials were targeted for violence while having a scheduled council meeting. The lawlessness that occurred in Flint City Council Chambers on October 14, 2024 is reprehensible and with a total disregard to the law. Hearing these individuals state and I quote 'I was was going for Tonya' …..and Ladel (Flint City Council President) was happy as he__……… It is very clear that a conspiracy to incite a riot was their clear plan. Residents, city department heads, and all others were scurrying to remove themselves from council chambers as the Vice President and President (Ladel) of the Flint City Council refused to enforce the disorderly conduct ordinance to bring order to the council chambers and allowed peoples lives to be put in jeopardy causing a very dangerous threatening situation. It is against the law to threaten ANY ELECTED OFFICIAL as the law speaks specifically to that as well as the consequences."
Councilwoman Jerri Winfrey-Carter, who represents the 5th Ward and shares the distinction as the council's longest-serving member with Councilwoman Burns, called on her colleagues to "do better" and blamed Monday's incident on Council President Dr. Lewis and Council Vice President Candace Mushatt of the 7th Ward.
WInfrey-Carter's statement said: "In my opinion, the unfortunate situation that unfolded at last night's council meeting was instigated by our council President and Vice President. Their actions and behavior incited a riot, disrupting what should been a productive and peaceful meeting. It is disheartening to witness leadership engage in conduct that inflames tensions rather than promoting respectful dialogue and unity among council members and the public. As elected officials, we are entrusted to serve and represent the people of Flint responsibly with professionalism and accountability. Last night's events fell far short of these expectations and we must do better for the community we are sworn to serve. I urge my colleagues on the council, especially our leadership, to reflect on the gravity of their actions and work toward restoring order and mutual respect in our proceedings moving forward."
County Commissioner Delrico Lloyd, a former Flint City Councilman in the 1st Ward, issued a lengthy statement that blasted the city's top elected leaders. It's included in the story at right if you are reading on a PC or laptop, or scroll down if you are reading on your mobile device.
Councilwoman Judy Priestly of the 4th Ward said on social media: "Council members animosity toward each other spreads into the public. I implore my fellow council members to be respectful of each other and their constituents. Each of us were elected and we try to serve our residents in the way that we feel is best for them and the city as a whole. I'm also asking members of the public to please be respectful during public speaking, not only to council members but also to the other residents on the City."
Eva Worthing, Flint's former 9th ward council member until resigning instead of fighting a recall election earlier this year, also took to social media to blast Councilwoman Burns. She said: "The irony of Tonya 'Karen' Burns calling the police. How dare she weaponize the police on innocent people who just wanted to attend a city council meeting?? Why is she afraid?? She loves it when people come to meetings to cause trouble. Oh wait. That's only the people she's friends with who antagonize her political enemies."
Councilman Pfeiffer was the first to issue a statement, taking to Facebook to say as follows:
“As a member of the Flint City Council, I find it deeply troubling to witness the events that unfolded at tonight's meeting. While not entirely unexpected, the behavior displayed was indeed appalling. The divisive tactics employed by the mayor and the council president, who have consistently leveraged racial rhetoric and misleading narratives, have led us to this point. Such strategies are not only misguided but are dangerously fracturing our community."
He added: "Tonight's meeting was marred by a clear intent from some audience members to disrupt and incite chaos, even threatening violence against fellow attendees. This is unacceptable in any civil society. More concerning is the apparent tolerance of such disruptive behavior by the council president, which suggests an agenda that prioritizes personal gain over community harmony and safety. Regrettably, the council president's failure to maintain order could be perceived as an endorsement of this chaos, fitting neatly into an agenda that appears to prioritize division over unity. We must reflect on these events and consider the kind of leadership we wish to see in our city. Leadership that unites rather than divides, that fosters peace rather than incites violence. I want to thank the Flint Police, Genesee County Sheriff, and the Michigan State Police that responded quickly and ensured the safety of all residents and staff during this event.”
Councilwoman Burns, who is black, also defended her white colleague Pfeiffer, saying, "The Flint City Council has faced many challenges this year, especially with the untimely death of two of our colleagues. The fact that Mayor Neeley is now gaslighting this community by using racial tactics targeting the ith ward council member is unprofessional, unwarranted and shameful. This type of rhetoric is not something this community needs as Mayor Neeley continues to keep the City Council separate and divided as well as all sides of town by race baiting. Mayor Neeley should use his time and words developing a 'Gang Task Force' and deal with the significant amount of children who have been shot, killed while sleeping within the safety of their homes."
PHOTO CAPTION: Pictured above this story is Beverly Biggs-Leavy. Her daughter pulled out a gun when family members of a former city councilman who passed away stormed toward her at a Flint City Council meeting. Police officers shut down the meeting but nobody has yet been arrested.